Friday, 5 December 2014

"Love in a World of Hate" by Bro Yap - 1 November



Personally I found this talk very insightful and applicable. It offered a Buddhist perspective of current affairs. Violence in the world goes in a cycle of being very violent to relatively peaceful then very violent again. Why should it have an impact on us?

One way is to see it as sth external, beyond our control. Very often we don't understand that external things are beyond our control and feel upset. We can look on things as external conditions. Things happen due to several external conditions coming together eg why people act a certain way, even if they seem very senseless there is a reason for their behaviour.

If we don't understand this, we will tend not to see things as they are and instead be swept by our judgments and emotions, and can even fall into depression. We have a tendency of blaming the situation.

Anything that arises will surely cease. When one of the conditions that creates the situation is no longer that, the situation will cease. Hence we should have patience that it will go away.
Eg if someone says something nasty, we will usually get angry. Before that, there wasn't anything. It is something external. Reacting does not create the conditions for it to go away but instead the person may say something nasty back and the situation may snowball. This is how many conflicts arise; over more minor things that snowball because people do not give them a chance to cease. It doesn't matter if they deserve to be scolded; just leave the matter and see their speech as just words. Don't provide the conditions for the conflict to continue.

Think of people like how dogs will bark. People are nasty due to conditions. Don't take their words so personally. They aren't perfect beings as we aren't, that's why we come to this path. It can be difficult, as we may have to correct years of bad habits.

Story: during Buddha's time, 2 clans were about to go to war. When asked, they pointed to the other party insulting them but were unsure of the original reason for conflict. The source turned out to be a quarrel between 2 farmers; one built a dam which deprived the other of water. The Buddha asked them if they would rather fill the river with blood or come to a compromise so all can share the water. They came to a compromise. We should go back to things in their raw form; we add layers and make mountains out of molehills. We should find the root cause whenever there are problems and conflict and resolve it from there.

Conditions change; things were different moments ago from now. When things aren't going our way, or it seems there is no way out, remember that things will change. These are just due to conditions that will change. Thinking about how we are suffering and how miserable we are will fuel our suffering even more. Be with nature, and this reminds us of the transient nature of things.

On an inner level we have hatred and anger which are suffering.
We must understand suffering before we can talk about other things. We often try to escape suffering instead of trying to understand it, thinking that our suffering will go away by going on holiday. We are unable to face it and see it for what it is.
Eg did badly for exams, try to hide it and avoid the issue which creates more problems.
Material things can't get us out of suffering. It will come back, and we may be unable to deal with it.
1st noble truth - understand there is suffering.
2nd noble truth - we must understand the cause, rather than escaping.
3rd noble truth - gives us hope.
4th noble truth - we have the ability to get out of suffering. Suffering comes about because of our own doing so it is within our power to get ourselves out of it
Experience these for ourselves and understand them, rather than just knowing what they are on paper.

Understanding suffering makes our happiness more long-lasting and satisfactory. If our happiness relies on having things, it is very unstable and fragile.

There is suffering with aging; we will lose our good looks, and cannot do what we used to do anymore.
Material things aren't symbols of happiness; just because we have them does not mean we have to be happy.

We should start with understanding 4 Noble Truths and Eightfold Path 
For the Eightfold Path, we take the 5 precepts to uphold morality. Pay a lot of attention to them.
The 5 precepts are not commandments, but to exercise restraint for our own good eg when there is anger. We are heirs to our own karma, we choose for ourselves 
right speech; avoid slandering, lying, gossiping which can be through social media, whatsapp etc in addition to talking. Instead we should practise using speech to convey kindness, love and concern for others. We should have the mindset of wanting to provide harmony, peace and non-violence wherever we are.
We should always question ourselves if we have broken the precepts. If we have try to make amends. If not, we don't have anything to worry. Precepts get us out of trouble eg by abstaining from alcohol, we will never go drink-driving.

Mental cultivation is for us to cultivate a peaceful mind. We spend lots of time grooming ourselves physically. But how often do we spend time grooming our mind? How often do we form judgments and prejudice and blame people and things?
No matter what we do, the physical will not last, we will age. However if we cultivate the mind it can only get stronger.

It's about our thoughts, our understanding. Understand that things are impermanent and are subject to conditions, if not we suffer.
Are we as full of anger, hatred and negativity as what's going on in the world? No need to be pessimistic. We have a choice no matter what happens. If a person is angry and stirs up anger in us, we can choose not to act rather than say we can't help it. We can choose whether to use wholesome or unwholesome speech. Regardless of what happens outside, we can still bring out our qualities of compassion and equanimity. We don't have to be affected and we can flourish the 4 immeasurables - compassion, loving-kindness, sympathetic joy and equanimity. The seeds are in us, try to decrease unwholesome tendencies and increase these wholesome ones. Enlightened beings demonstrate the human potential; they are physically similar to us but have cultivated their mind.

No matter what the conditions are, there are bound to be dissatisfactory conditions; there is no ideal world. Even subtle things like not getting the grades we want or things not going our way are suffering. Ask ourselves why we suffer; reflect. We would often blame and ask why people are like that but fail to look inwards.

"The Hunger for Suffering" by Bro Wen Jie - 25 October



All teachings have the 4 Noble Truths and Eightfold Path as their backbone. Trying to acquire more knowledge is good, but if one is acquiring for one's ego there is little wisdom acquired.

People are influenced by culture eg Japanese, Korean; they unconsciously take it on. The Buddhist practice is a culture as well.
When taking on a culture, doubts arise eg why do guys perm hair? Question the use of metal chopsticks, if they'll be scalding if the food is hot?
Similarly, in the Buddhist practice we may start questioning a lot. The Buddha encourages us to investigate the teachings for ourselves, but if there are too much doubts, they become hindrances such that we end up not taking on the culture, and not learning. An issue is that we carry our baggages and past opinions and as a result we may not be receptive. Eg we may question: why bother making a room extra clean for a monk when we find it clean enough? This is because it is a way to repay the kindness of the monk, who teaches us and can't receive money for his service. In fact, doing these things train the mind. Staying with monks we see how mindful they are even with little things; they have 227 precepts and need to have a high level of mindfulness to keep them.

After immersing in the culture for some time then we start to understand.
When deciding whether to clean or not, defilements, excuses of laziness kick in. Realize that confusion all boils down to wanting to know. We will know when we arrive at the state of mind where there is no confusion. Confusion affects meditation; the mind will always run and never be still when the meditator is not sharp enough.

The hard part is immersing oneself in the culture. The biggest issue is ego; having own ideas and being unwilling to submit oneself to the culture. For example, one may not see the point of bowing, or the Thai male and female ways of kneeling.

Question ourselves: what is the practice? It transforms us and we can do what we already do better. It is submitting oneself to the routine in a monastery with no questions.
Like going to the gym, the first time we just ache. Keep going and develop muscles. Keep going in the practice. It's about the  Noble Eightfold Path but our issue is submitting ourselves to it.

3 aspects of each Noble Truth.

1st Noble Truth
Statement: there is suffering.
Prescription: suffering should be understood.

What is suffering? What is there to be understood?
Buddha never explained suffering because we all know what it is. The problem with us is that we don't know what causes it. Clinging to 5 Aggregates; things that are impermanent brings it about. We think that other things cause suffering. We watch tv, eat good food etc because we think not having those is suffering.

Result: suffering has been understood.

2nd Noble Truth
Statement: the cause of suffering is desire.
Prescription: desire has to be let go of.

We don't see birth, aging, sickness, death, especially when we are young and think our youth and energy is permanent. We cling to it.
When we have pain eg during meditation, we don't realise that when we are about to die, the pain will be a lot more severe. About all of the dying patients in hospitals are prescribed antidepressants; we have the delusion that we won't be like them.

Result: desire has been let go of.

3rd Noble Truth
Statement: there is a way out of suffering.
Prescription: the way out of suffering should be realised.
Result: the way out of suffering has been realised.

4th Noble Truth
Statement: the way out of suffering is the Noble Eightfold Path.
Prescription: the Noble Eightfold Path should be cultivated.
Result: the Noble Eightfold Path has been cultivated.

It sounds simplistic but can only be internalized by immersing ourselves in the practice.
None of us are lacking in effort and energy. The problem is that we put these  into the wrong things. Eg IPPT used to be effortless for Bro Wen Jie, but as he aged he trained hard but barely passed. Other egs are knowledge, money, girlfriend etc. These things are acquired but they will go one day. Hence we are wasting our time in a way. The practice is what will go up and not come down in the present and future lives as long as we are consistent. Therefore putting energy to it is important. Hence the need for Right View.

Chanki Sutta
The Buddha was having a conversation with a group of older Brahmins when a young Brahmin interjected. The Buddha told him off for doing so but the older Brahmins wanted to let him speak as he was very smart. The young Brahmin asked the Buddha questions.

Wise position: if you are not awakened, when asked a question you should say "as far as I know this is true but for the rest, I don't know."
To decide on whether to follow a teacher, observe him and see if he does not have greed, hatred and delusion. If he passes then visit him and listen to what he has to say and remember it. Then penetrate the meaning. If it makes sense to you, come into agreement with the Dhamma. Upon having the desire to listen to it more, contemplate the teachings even more ie do in your practice. Then exert yourself by putting in energy into the practice. Then you will penetrate the truth even more. Repeat the cycle until you arrive at a truth. This is where the greatest safeguard is.

One has to be discerning, and most importantly exert it to have right view.

"Learning From Nature" by Dr Henry Yeo - 29 November


This was a discussion-based talk. Hence some of the insights I wrote are shared by the Youths.

He started off by showing us a video of nature. The takeaway point is that we are often caught up in the office etc but forget how small we are in relation to nature. Nature isn't always perfect, with 4 seasons and rain. Buddha, Jesus etc walked in nature. Nature helps us appreciate our surroundings and confront our own thoughts.

A river has to crash and fall to reach the beautiful valley, but it moves on without complaint. Just like our life which isn't smooth-sailing. We have to have the determination to go on to reach the valley of peace.

The significance of the lotus in Buddhism:
Waxy surface; anything rolls off just as insults roll off an enlightened one. It grows in harsh conditions but emerges beautiful.
In a lotus pond, some young ones are waiting to emerge while some lotuses are dying. We can us this to contemplate the life cycle.

Ajahn Brahm's story of falling leaves: during a storm, not just old leaves and branches fall on the ground, but young leaves do as well. Just like human lives, it is natural that some die young.

When we go out in the open, the variation of colours, sounds etc is much wider than in the city. We take many things for granted in the city. Everything is interconnected. We often want perfection eg perfect partner, perfect body, but in nature there are hardly 2 trees that are the same, some have broken branches etc. Everything is unique in its own way and more beautiful. A short exercise we can do is to plant a small seed. See that everything arises from causes and conditions; dependent on many factors like water and sunlight. Plant a durian seed and get a durian plant. Similarly we reap the seeds we plant.

If we are frightened in nature we should go back to breath meditation and wish ourselves to be well and happy.

Most of us are like mudskippers, complacent, basking in the sun, without a thought for the next day. We are like mayflies that just mate, having fun, and then get eaten by swallows. We can see how things in nature relate to Dhamma.

Living in the city we feel we can control a lot of things eg what we want to eat. Nature has its own rules and we are just a small part of it. 

Ajahn Brahm's story: 
Walking up a hill one notices a lot more things than if one were driven. In our life we are in a hurry to do many things eg get a degree, HDB, so we forget to enjoy the journey. 

Even in the city we can look at our surroundings and see the beauty rather than the floor. Good to know a few names of plants, birds so we appreciate them when we can identify them. Good to meditate by the sea. On a windy day the breeze can be a meditation object.

In life, we get enlightened for a tiny moment in nature eg beautiful sunset. That is because we are so absorbed we forget that 'I' exists and becomes one with nature with a gladness to see it. Life is like a rainbow, it goes away quickly.

We think we are very strong but in nature we are a lot weaker than we think we are. Eg in the snow, we may easily chop off our toes because the axe can slip due to numb fingers. If a log drops we may not be able to get up no matter how much we can lift weights at the gym. Forgive ourselves for that and acknowledge nature is more powerful.

We tend to quantify things eg I'm a good Buddhist if I reach 3rd jhana. We are missing the point. What is important is if we come out a better person.

A lot of times we are angry with nature eg rain but there's no point many things are beyond our control. Including other people whose actions we cannot control so there is no point getting angry with them.

A story as a analogy: a man tripped over a hump. He cursed the ground for making him dirty so dug it to teach it a lesson. He did not realize he was getting dirtier and eventually dropped into the hole. He cursed but do you think the earth cares? 

When the mud has settled in a pond it becomes so clear. Just like when our mind is settled it becomes so clear.
We should take time off to go for walks in nature. It lifts the mood. The mind plays a big part in nature eg we may be calm, or imagine fearful things in the unknown.

Dhamma in nature - impermanence, dissatisfaction and non-self. We are not in control. The body is not ours, it will go back to nature which is the 4 elements, earth, fire, water and air. We are made of mind and matter. We can only shape our future through our kamma.

Who would expect the Himalayas was once a sea? Reflecting on death and nature, pick up a scoop of sand on the beach. There are shells which were once living animals. These contributed to the sand on the beach.

Make use of awareness of our surroundings in our practice. Assume a humbling attitude there's much we don't know.

Notes from One Day Guided Meditation by Phra Chun Kiang - 18 October


8 kinds of suffering:
1. Birth
2. Aging
3. Sickness
4. Death
5. Separation from loved ones
6. Associating with people you don't like
7. Not getting what we want
8. The 5 clinging aggregates - form, feeling, perception, mental formations, consciousness - 5 senses + mind
Eg when we see Venerable that is eye consciousness. We see form and feeling arises; pleasant, unpleasant or neutral. Mental formations, what the mind starts to think, arise.

Meditation helps us to understand workings of the mind. We are studying ourselves.

Craving for sensual pleasures is greed. 
Craving for becoming is because we don't want to let go of pleasant feelings eg eating something very nice.
Craving for non-becoming is hatred of sth unpleasant. Eg if Venerable scolds us vulgarities we will feel unpleasant as we hate the vulgarities being directed at us.

We should go into meditation with right thought. Some ppl may meditate to get psychic powers which is wrong intention. The benchmark is: are we reducing greed, hatred and delusion?

It is better for a sick patient to go to consult a doctor than to attend health conference. A dhamma talk is like a health conference, a general guideline for many people. It is better to do our own practice and have personal consultation for our issues.

During the retreat we did breath meditation, walking meditation and loving-kindness meditation.
Breath meditation involves being aware of the breath, breathing in and out.
Walking meditation involves focusing on the movement of our feet as we walk.
Loving-kindness meditation involves radiating loving-kindness to ourselves and other beings, wishing all to be well and happy, and free from suffering and danger.